I Just Gotta Know…

One of my buddies from work was teasing me about my sandwich today. Apparently, he’d neve seen anyone eat peanut butter the way I do.

So I ask you. What do you eat your peanut butter with?

1) Jelly
2) Bananas
3) Cheese
4) ??

25 thoughts on “I Just Gotta Know…”

  1. Um, so I’m picturing that you’ve got the peanut butter spread between two hot guys, and …..
    Sorry, lost my train of thought when I read ‘cheese’. You don’t really put cheese together with PB, do you?

  2. I don’t mix my peanut butter with anything–I keep it segregated… it’s better that way 🙂

    Uhhh, do you eat peanut butter and cheese sandwiches?

  3. Peanut butter and butter sandwiches, mmmmmm. Toasting the bread makes it extra special too = )

    ummmm What is up with the PB/cheese??? That’s just too weird for me, lol

  4. I love peanut butter, so I am pretty open-minded as to what I’ll eat it with. For example, I love an english muffin with peanut butter and a big slice of canadian bacon. It sounds strange, but it is AWESOME. Now if I could only get Skippy to make their “natural” brand in a larger size…

  5. Peanut butter and cheese SEEMS unusual, but what about those PB sandwich crackers from vending machines–the crackers are flavored with cheddar cheese.

    I tend to eat PB by itself, but of the choices given, jelly would be my preference.

    And Vegimite? EEEEEEEWWWWWWWWWWWW!!!!!

  6. Yes, I like peanut butter w/cheese. American is my favorite. I also like it w/bananas. I like in on celery w/cheese too!

    There! My secrets out! I’m a closted peanut butter lover!

  7. Jelly (grape only) on whole wheat bread. Or on celery (crunchy PB). Or on a bagel. I might try it with cheese now though …

  8. When we were kids, we’d ask for “all threes”- peanut butter, apple butter, and butter. YUM! I think we also called them “three ways”, but that has a completely different meaning now-a-days doesn’t it?

  9. Jelly. Grape Jelly only. Preferabaly Smuckers.

    …though I do have a friend who LOVES peanut butter w/marshmellow fluff. yuck!

  10. OK, so I can’t believe out of all of these comments that no one has mentioned HONEY. I think that’s all we grew up with was PB&Honey sandwiches…..sometimes jelly, but seldom. And, furthermore, even those these sandwiches sound pretty damn yummy, there are even more nasty (naughty may be a more appropriate word) ways to have one’s PB.

  11. Moby – where are the fags? Apparently not commenting on your blog!!!

    1.) Jam (not jelly) pref. Blackberry or Raspberry
    2.) Honey (Raw & flavored)
    3.) Fluff
    4.) Raisins
    5.) Slivered Almonds
    6.) Toasted Pecans
    7.) Thinly sliced or smashed bananas
    8.) Mix Peanut Butter w/ cinnamon & sugar
    9.) Any dried fruit (cranberries, especially)
    10.) Stewed Prunes (wonderful!)
    11.) Lemon Curd
    12.) Cheese (mild cheddar, colby, cream cheese or mixed with ricotta for a dip, sandwich spread, celery filling)
    13.) Figs
    14.) Peeled & sliced oranges, pears or apples
    15.) Pomegranite
    16.) Kiwi
    17.) Sprinkle a little cardamom or pumpkin pie spice on the peanut butter

    AND WHO COULD #@#$%#$^& FORGET

    (drum roll ….)

    18.) CHOCOLATE

Comments are closed.